Saturday, June 14, 2008

Glossary Supply Chain

Glossary

activity-based costing (ABC)
A technique for allocating indirect costs to production activities, making indirect costs more comparable to direct costs and permitting a better assessment of the true cost of creating each product.
 
advanced planning and scheduling (APS) system
A type of software that uses mathematical models and related techniques to find optimal solutions to complex production and supply problems.
See also [optimizer]
See also [linear programming]
advance shipping notice (ASN)
A document sent by a supplier to a customer to indicate when an order will be shipped. ASNs are usually transmitted electronically.
 
aggregate forecast
A forecast based on product or customer data that has been grouped by similarity.
See also [aggregation]
aggregation
The practice of grouping similar products or customers to simplify planning and achieve more stable forecasts.
 
assemble-to-order strategy
The practice of building product components in advance of demand, but postponing final assembly until demand is realized. An intermediate strategy between the make-to-stock and make-to-order strategies.
 
available to promise (ATP)
The inventory status of a product that is currently on hand and available for immediate shipment.
See also [capable to promise]
back scheduling
The practice of scheduling activities by working backward from the planned completion date, adding activities to the schedule in the reverse order in which they will be executed.
See also [forward scheduling]
backhaul
A shipment that moves in the opposite direction along a route just taken by a vehicle in making a delivery, allowing it to make use of its hauling capacity on the return trip.
 
bill of lading
A document listing all the goods contained within a shipment and stating the terms governing its transportation. Some bills of lading also serve as title to the goods.
 
bill of materials (BOM)
A listing of the parts and materials that become part of a finished product, organized in a hierarchical structure that reflects their components, subassemblies, or intermediate forms.
 
bill of operations (BOO)
A list of the procedures necessary to produce a finished product from its constituent materials, organized as a hierarchical structure that reflects the sequence in which these procedures must be carried out..
 
bullwhip effect
An alternative name for demand amplification.
 
capable to promise (CTP)
The inventory status of a product that is not immediately on hand but that can be produced within the required fulfillment lead time..
See also [available to promise]
captive exchange
A private electronic exchange that is owned by one or more of the participating organizations and restricted to selected trading partners of the owning organizations.
See also [private exchange]
See also [public exchange]
carrier
A company that specializes in transporting goods.
 
carrying cost
The incremental cost of placing orders due to increases in product quantities. So named because the majority of this variable cost is the expense of carrying inventory that is not immediately consumed. Also known as holding cost.
See also [order cost]
cash-to-cash time
A measure of the efficiency with which cash is used in the business. Calculated as the interval between the time a company pays for raw materials and the time it receives payment for the finished goods produced from those materials.
 
category management
The practice of organizing inventory management, promotions, and related activities around products that consumers view as roughly equivalent in meeting their needs.
 
collaborative planning, forecasting, and replenishment (CPFR)
A multi-industry program that uses the Internet to achieve cooperation across the members of a supply chain to better forecast, plan, and execute the flow of goods.
 
conceptual model
A representation of a real-world system, such as a supply chain, that is constructed out of terms and concepts of the sort listed in this glossary. Conceptual models are expressed as diagrams and descriptions.
See also [mathematical model]
See also [simulation model]
confidence interval
A range of numbers within which a predicted value will fall with a specified probability. For example, 9 out of 10 observations will fall within a 90% confidence interval. Confidence intervals are often shown in graphs as small bars above and below the expected value to indicate the range of likely values.
 
consignment
An inventory control practice in which a supplier maintains ownership of inventory on a customer's site until the inventory is sold, monitoring its level and replenishing it as needed.
 
constraint
In an optimization procedure, a mathematical expression or equation that restricts the range of solutions the method will evaluate. A typical constraint would be an upper bound on capital spending in the design of a supply chain.
See also [linear programming]
consumer
The individual or organization that acquires a product in order to use it for its intended purpose rather than reselling it to someone else. As the terms are used in this book, a consumer is a special type of customer.
 
continuous replenishment (CR) program
An extension of the quick response (QR) program to cover the full range of retail merchandise and to add the techniques of supplier forecasting and vendor-managed inventory.
 
continuous review
An inventory replenishment policy in which a continuous count of inventory is maintained at all times, with orders being placed whenever the count falls below a set threshold.
See also [periodic review]
cross dock
A specialized facility for transferring in-transit inventory between trucks. Typically a long building consisting primarily of receiving docks on one side, shipping docks on the other, and assembly areas between the two. Although nominally a type of storage facility, cross docks do not usually hold goods for more than 24 hours.
 
cross docking
The practice of using cross docks or distribution centers to reallocate shipments across trucks en route from suppliers to customers, allowing each truck to remain full throughout its journey. Products are moved directly from receiving docks to shipping docks, with no intermediate storage.
 
customer
The individual or organization that purchases a product or service in a supply chain transaction. The term is used inconsistently throughout the business literature, leading to unproductive debates over who the "real" customer is. In this book, the term is used to denote a role within a transaction and can be applied to any link in the chain. In this usage, the final customer is the consumer at the end of the supply chain.
 
customer schedule
A special format for an order spanning multiple shipments in which line items are grouped by delivery date.
 
customer service level (CSL)
The target level of product availability for a particular region and product. Service level can be specified in wide a variety of ways, ranging from the maximum distance of inventory from a customer's site to the percent of orders that can be filled from inventory within a specified time.
 
cycle stock
The amount of inventory required to support the operations of a facility, with no reserve to cover unforeseen events.
See also [safety stock]
cycle time
This term is used to denote either (a) the interval between successive repetitions of a cyclical process, as in the cycle time of a machine or assembly line, or (b) the duration of a business process. These conflicting definitions lead to confusion and reduce the value of the term.
 
days on hand
A measure of inventory level, calculated by dividing the quantity on hand by the average daily consumption. Provides the same information as the inventory turnover ratio but in a form more suitable to high-turn environments.
 
delayed differentiation
A technique in which products with characteristics in common are left in their common form until demand is realized, allowing a better match of production to realized demand. Also called postponement.
 
Delphi technique
A procedure in which forecasts generated by multiple analysts are repeatedly combined and reviewed until a consensus forecast is reached.
 
demand amplification
The tendency for fluctuations in demand to increase as they move up the supply chain. Often referred to as the bullwhip effect in recent literature.
 
demand lumping
A phenomenon in which an otherwise smooth flow of demand up a supply chain is grouped into larger chunks than is necessary to meet operational requirements. Demand lumping is a major contributor to demand amplification. It is known to be caused by batching, forward buying, and hoarding.
 
dependent demand
The demand for a product from customers who are not the end consumers of that product. So named because this demand ultimately depends on consumer demand.
See also [independent demand]
design for supply
The practice of engineering a product in a way that facilitates its flow through the supply chain.
 
direct shipment
A distribution practice in which goods that would normally move by way of a warehouse or distribution center are transported directly from a supplier to a customer.
 
distribution center (DC)
A storage facility in which goods may be staged, sorted, assembled, packaged, and/or stored temporarily as they pass through a particular segment of a supply chain. Distribution centers differ from warehouses primarily in the focus on facilitating distribution rather than holding inventory.
 
distribution network
The set of facilities and lanes that transports finished goods from a production facility to the downstream customers of that facility. A distribution network may be divided into echelons.
 
dynamic forecasting
The practice of revising current forecasts at the end of each period to incorporate the data for that period rather than leaving these forecasts unchanged over successive periods.
See also [static forecasting]
echelon
In a distribution network, a set or layer of facilities functionally equidistant from the production facility that serves them. Comparable to a tier in a procurement network.
 
echelon inventory
When centrally managed, the total inventory distributed across the echelons of a distribution network.
 
economic order quantity (EOQ)
The calculated amount of inventory that should be ordered at one time to minimize the total cost of replenishment, taking into account the opposing effects of order costs and holding costs.
 
efficient consumer response (ECR)
A supply-chain program used in the grocery industry that combines rapid retail replenishment with the techniques of category management and activity-based costing.
 
efficient frontier
A curve describing the most advantageous possible combination of cost and flexibility in a supply chain. This curve is constantly being advanced by best practices in supply chain management.
 
electronic auction
An auction conducted entirely over the Internet, with sellers submitting products to a Web site and buyers using e-mail or Web browsers to place their bids..
 
electronic catalog
A directory of products stored in digital form, usually accessible over the Web, that provides access to product by type and supplier.
 
electronic data interchange (EDI)
A set of protocols for transferring information regarding demand and supply over private electronic networks.
 
electronic distribution
The practice of shipping products in electronic form across the Internet or other electronic medium. Electronic distribution is used for music, documents, software, photographs, tickets, and other products that can be transmitted in digital form.
 
electronic exchange
A digital marketplace, accessible over the Web, that brings together buyers and sellers of a particular type of product and provides them with tools for carrying out transactions.
 
enterprise resource planning (ERP) system
A suite of software that combines tactical-level applications for production and distribution planning with execution systems for order management, inventory control, accounting, and related operations.
 
external supply chain
The portion of a supply chain that spans facilities outside the ownership boundaries of a particular company.
See also [internal supply chain]
extractor
A special kind of supplier that takes raw materials from the earth in either living or inert form. Examples include mines, saw mills, farms, and ranches.
 
extrinsic factor
An influence on demand or some other supply chain characteristic that is beyond a firm's control, such as the state of the economy or the actions of a competitor.
 
feedback
A physical or information flow from the output of a system into the input side of that system. The appropriate use of feedback is essential for regulating the behavior of a system.
See also [positive feedback]
See also [negative feedback]
finished goods inventory
The store of completed products on the output side of a production facility.
 
forecast horizon
The date furthest in the future for which events are predicted in a forecast.
 
formal model
A business model that can be expressed in mathematical or executable form, allowing it to generate numerical predictions from a set of inputs. Of the three types of models discussed in this book, mathematical and simulation models are formal while conceptual models are not.
 
forward buying
The practice of buying supplies before they are needed to take advantage of favorable prices or avoid potential shortages.
 
forward scheduling
The practice of scheduling activities by beginning with the planned start date and adding activities to the schedule in the order in which they will be executed.
See also [back scheduling]
fulfillment cycle
The sequence of events in a supplier organization that manage the three key flows in the fulfillment process: order flow, product flow, and cash flow.
 
fulfillment lead time
The interval between the time an order is placed with a supplier and the time the goods are received by the customer.
 
full pallet
A pallet of goods that contains only a single kind of product.
See also [mixed pallet]
full truckload (FTL) shipment
A shipment of goods that consumes the capacity of a truck, requiring the truck to be dedicated to the shipment.
See also [less-than-truckload (LTL) shipment]
hill-climbing
A technique used to search for a superior configuration of a system such as a supply chain by making a series of small, beneficial changes to the system until no further improvements appear to be possible.
 
holding cost
The incremental cost of placing orders due to increases in product quantities. So named because the majority of this variable cost is the expense of holding inventory that is not immediately consumed. Also known as carrying cost.
See also [order cost]
independent demand
The demand for a product on the part of its end consumers. So named because it is the ultimate source of demand, and doesn't depend on a source of demand further down in the supply chain.
See also [dependent demand]
inter-modal transportation
The practice of using more than one medium of transportation, such as rail and ship, within a single shipment.
 
internal supply chain
The portion of a supply chain that joins the facilities owned by the same company.
See also [external supply chain]
in-transit inventory
Inventory that is currently in a transportation lane between two facilities.
 
intrinsic factor
An influence on demand or some other supply chain characteristic that is within a firm's control, such as the price of a product or the speed of delivery.
 
inventory turnover ratio
A measure of how quickly inventory is used once it arrives at a facility, calculated as the annual sales of a product divided by its average inventory level.
 
inventory turns
Shorthand for inventory turnover ratio.
 
inventory velocity
The speed with which inventory moves through the supply chain. Despite the way the term is commonly used, it does not represent a measure of performance, and companies that seek to increase their inventory velocity continue to rely on such traditional measures as the inventory turnover ratio and days on hand.
 
item fill rate
The percentage of line items, calculated across all orders, for which the full quantity of the requested product is available for immediate shipment.
See also [order fill rate]
judgmental techniques
The collection of forecasting techniques based on cause-and-effect reasoning rather than statistical analysis. Also known as subjective techniques.
 
just-in-time (JIT) manufacturing
The practice of reducing inventory levels by scheduling materials to arrive just as they are needed in the production process. More broadly, a comprehensive program for improving manufacturing operations to yield higher quality products at reduced expense.
 
keiretsu
The Japanese term for a type of integration in which a manufacturing firm takes partial ownership positions in key suppliers and appoints its own personnel to some management positions.
 
less-than-truckload (LTL) shipment
A shipment of goods that consumes only a fraction of the capacity of a truck, requiring that the truck be shared with other shipments.
See also [full truckload (FTL) shipment]
level component
In time-series analysis, the portion of the forecast demand that is constant and unvarying.
See also [trend]
See also [seasonal]
See also [random components]
linear programming (LP)
A technique for finding optimal solutions to mathematical models in which all relations between inputs and outputs are linear in form.
 
make-to-order strategy
The practice of making products in response to realized demand rather than making them to stock in advance of demand.
 
make-to-stock strategy
The practice of making products in advance of demand and holding them in finished goods inventory until demand is realized.
 
mathematical model
A representation of a real-world system, such as a supply chain, that is constructed out of mathematical terms and relations. Mathematical models are expressed as formulas and/or procedures for solving equations to predict the behavior of the system.
See also [conceptual model]
See also [simulation model]
mean absolute percentage error (MAPE)
A measure of the average deviation between forecast values and their corresponding observed values, regardless of the direction (sign) of those deviations.
See also [tracking signal]
merge in transit
A technique in which separate shipments are combined en route and delivered as a single unit.
 
mixed pallet
A pallet of goods that contains two or more kinds of products.
See also [full pallet]
mode of transportation
The medium by which a vehicle moves products from one facility to another. The primary modes are truck, rail, boat, barge, airplane, and pipeline.
 
Monte Carlo method
The technique of running a simulation model repeatedly using random variables on each run in order to understand behavior of the model across normal variations of business conditions.
 
moving average
The mean value obtained by summing the last N values of a measure and dividing by N, where N is set according to need. Used in forecasting and other applications to obtain a typical value for recent observations of some measure. Increasing the value of N produces more stable values that are less sensitive to recent changes.
 
negative feedback
A form of feedback in which movement of an output of a system in a particular direction is decreased, decelerating that movement. Negative feedback usually leads to stable, bounded outputs that facilitate control of a system.
See also [positive feedback]
objective function
In linear programming, the equation that defines the quantity being optimized, such as total cost or a weighted combination of cost and other performance measures.
 
on-time delivery
A measure of fulfillment effectiveness, calculated as the percentage of orders that arrive at the customer site within the agreed-upon time.
 
optimization
Using a mathematical or procedural technique to explore the space of all possible configurations of a system and identify the configuration that maximizes (or minimizes) a designated output measure. Optimization is usually carried out using a specialized program called an optimizer.
See also [linear programming]
optimizer
A software program capable of automating the process of optimizing a system using a particular mathematical or procedural technique.
See also [optimization]
See also [linear programming]
order cost
The fixed cost of placing an order, regardless of the quantities involved.
See also [holding cost]
order fill rate
The percentage of orders for which the full quantities of all products on the order are available for immediate shipment.
See also [item fill rate]
packing slip
A document enclosed with a shipment that lists the goods included in that shipment together with information about the origin, destination, and means of transport.
 
parameter
A quantity whose value is set prior to performing an analysis that depends on that quantity. Example: Order cost and holding cost are parameters used in the calculation of economic order quantity.
 
Pareto Analysis
A technique for analyzing sales data to determine the extent to which a small number of products accounts for the majority of sales. A common result, often stated as the 80:20 rule, is that 80% of sales come from 20% of the products.
 
perfect order
A measure of fulfillment effectiveness, calculated as the percentage of orders that ship complete, arrive on time, contain the correct goods, are free of damage, and have accurate paperwork.
 
periodic review
An inventory replenishment policy in which inventory is counted at fixed intervals and orders are placed whenever the current count falls below a set threshold.
See also [continuous review]
point of sale (POS) system
A software application that prices and records the sale of products to customers who are physically on site and take immediate possession of their purchases.
 
positioning strategy
The set of attributes on which a company chooses to differentiate itself from its competition, together with methods for improving those attributes and communicating them to potential customers. In the manufacturing sector, the most common attributes are quality of product, quality of service, and price.
 
positive feedback
A form of feedback in which movement of an output of a system in a particular direction is increased, accelerating that movement. If unchecked by other mechanisms, positive feedback usually leads to exponential growth and "out of control" behavior.
See also [negative feedback]
postponement
An alternate term for delayed differentiation.
 
primary packaging
The level of packaging that immediately encloses a product, such as a bottle, box, can, or blister pack.
See also [secondary packaging]
See also [transport packaging]
private exchange
An electronic exchange with membership rules that exclude parties that would otherwise be qualified to buy and sell the products handled on the exchange.
See also [public exchange]
procurement network
The set of facilities and lanes that transports raw materials to a production facility from the upstream suppliers of that facility. A procurement network may be divided into tiers.
 
production facility
A facility that exists primarily to create products from raw materials, storing materials and products only as necessary to support production operations.
See also [storage facility]
public exchange
An electronic exchange that is open to all qualified buyers and sellers of the products handled on the exchange.
See also [private exchange]
pull chain
A supply chain in which inventory is produced only in response to realized demand at each stage of the chain, with product being "pulled" down the chain by actual orders.
 
push chain
A supply chain in which inventory is produced in advance of demand and "pushed" down the chain toward the consumer.
 
push-pull boundary
The point in a supply chain in which the driving force switches from pull to push, with pull operating downstream to the consumer and push acting upstream to the extractor.
 
quick response (QR)
A supply chain program on the part of the apparel industry that applied just-in-time (JIT) techniques to retail replenishment.
 
random component
In time-series analysis, the variability in demand that remains after the systematic components have been removed. In other words, the aspect of demand that can't be forecast by the model.
 
raw materials inventory
The inventory of incoming materials maintained at a production facility for use in the production process.
 
relation
In systems, a mapping of inputs to outputs that yields one or more outputs for any given input. Relations are usually described by one or more lines in a graph, and they range in form from straight lines (linear relations) to complex curves.
 
reorder point (ROP)
The level or count at which the inventory for a particular product is replenished.
 
replenishment cycle
The sequence of events within a customer organization that manage the three key flows in the replenishment process: order flow, product flow, and cash flow.
 
replenishment lead time
The interval between the time a company places an order for raw materials and the time it receives those materials.
 
replenishment policy
The set of rules by which a firm decides when to replenish its inventory, how large to make its orders, and how much inventory to maintain on site.
 
reverse auction
An auction in which customers post requests for quotes and suppliers bid against each other to win the business.
 
risk pooling
An inventory management technique in which the safety stock necessary to handle expected fluctuations in supply and demand is reduced by treating two or more physically separate inventories as a single logical inventory.
 
safety stock
The amount of inventory that must be maintained in order to handle fluctuations in supply and demand.
See also [cycle stock]
seasonal component
In time-series analysis, the portion of the forecast demand that varies in a cyclical manner over the course of the year.
See also [level]
See also [trend]
See also [random components]
secondary packaging
The level of packaging that groups a standard number of primary packages together for convenience in handling, storage, and sales. The most common form of secondary packaging is the carton.
 
sell-through
The amount of stock acquired by a customer under a promotion that is passed on to that customer's customers during the promotional period. Suppliers may limit the amount of product a customer can buy under a promotion to the sell-through amount in order to reduce forward buying.
 
ship complete
A constraint placed on an order that requires all items in the order to arrive in a single shipment.
 
shrinkage
The reduction in inventory that occurs through pilferage, misplacement, and related forms of attrition.
 
simulation model
A representation of a real-world system, such as a supply chain, that is constructed out of software objects that represent real-world objects. Simulation models are expressed as computer programs that execute the models to observe their expected behavior.
See also [conceptual model]
See also [mathematical model]
static forecasting
The practice of generating a forecast and then leaving it unchanged until a new forecast is created.
See also [dynamic forecasting]
stockout
The situation in which there is not enough inventory on hand to fill a received order.
 
storage facility
A facility that exists primarily to hold goods in anticipation of future demand. Some storage facilities may also perform final assembly and packaging in order to move these operations closer to the end consumer.
See also [production facility]
subjective techniques
The collection of forecasting techniques based on cause-and-effect reasoning rather than statistical analysis. Also known as judgmental techniques.
 
supplier
The organization that provides a product or service in a supply chain transaction. In this book, the term is used as a counterpart to customer, denoting a role within a transaction that can be applied to any link in the chain. In some contexts, the term refers specifically to companies that provide raw materials and is not applied to downstream members of the chain.
 
supply chain
A network of facilities and transportation lanes that transforms raw materials into finished products and delivers those products to consumers.
 
supply chain management (SCM)
The set of activities involved in designing, planning, and executing the flow of demand, supply, and cash across a supply chain.
 
systematic component
In time-series analysis, any component of demand (level, trend, or seasonal) that can be predicted from the model. In other words, everything but the random component .
See also [level]
See also [trend]
See also [seasonal components]
tier
In a procurement network, a set or layer of facilities functionally equidistant from the production facility they serve. Comparable to an echelon in a distribution network.
 
time-series analysis
A forecasting technique in which future values of a measure are predicted from a mathematical analysis of historical values of that measure.
 
tipping point
A phenomenon observed in the spread of ideas in which the prevalence of the idea makes a sudden leap from a slow-growth curve to a different, fast-growth curve. Originally discovered in the study of infectious diseases and subsequently found to apply to product sales, crime waves, and other social activities.
 
tracking signal
A measure of the bias of a forecast to either overestimate or underestimate the observed value.
See also [mean absolute percentage error (MAPE)]
transport packaging
A level of packaging, such as a pallet, that is added to facilitate shipping and storing large quantities of product.
See also [primary packaging]
See also [secondary packaging]
transportation lane
A designated pathway for moving goods from one facility to the next within in a supply chain. Lanes are categorized as highways, railways, waterways, air lanes, and pipelines.
 
transshipment
A technique in which goods are shipped laterally within the same echelon of a distribution system, such as between warehouses or between retail stores.
 
trend component
In time-series analysis, the portion of the forecast demand that shows a constant, linear increase over time.
See also [level]
See also [seasonal]
See also [random components]
turn-and-earn system
A policy in which suppliers limit customer purchases to the quantity of goods they "turn" by shipping them out as finished goods to their own customers. Used to reduce hoarding during periods of limited availability.
 
vendor-managed inventory (VMI)
An inventory control practice in which a supplier monitors and replenishes inventory on a customer's site.
 
vertical integration
The practice of owning facilities across a large segment of a supply chain in order to control as much of the chain as possible.
See also [virtual integration]
virtual integration
A practice in which members of a supply chain collaborate closely with each other in order to gain the benefits of centralized supply chain management while retaining independent ownership and control.
See also [vertical integration]
warehouse
A storage facility that holds controlled quantities of goods in a particular location within a supply chain.
See also [distribution center]
Web services
A set of technologies that allows software programs to invoke each other's functions using XML and standard Internet protocols.
 
work-in-process (WIP) inventory
Inventory currently being used in a production process or held for use within the production area. Includes all materials that have been removed from raw materials inventory but not yet deposited in finished goods inventory.
 
XML
The extensible markup language for communicating data in a structured format over the Internet.
 
zero-sum game
Any interaction between two parties in which the total gain across the two is fixed, leaving the parties to compete with each other over their relative shares of that gain. Many supply chain relationships that are traditionally viewed as zero-sum interactions are actually much richer than this, including outcomes in which the total gain can be increased or decreased depending on how the parties conduct themselves.


Bring your gang together.. Do your thing. Find your favourite Yahoo! Group.

Tuesday, June 3, 2008

Growing CEOs from the Inside

Author: Sean Silverthorne

There is no more important decision a board can make than naming a CEO. Yet most companies pay scant attention to the issue of succession other than a few whispered names in the hallways. The result? The hiring of an outsider who quickly gets mired in legacy and obstinacy, or an insider who knows the business but can't lead.

"The best leaders are people from inside the company who somehow have maintained enough detachment from the local traditions, ideologies, and shibboleths that they have retained the objectivity of an outsider," Bower writes.

Think Anne Mulcahy, CEO of Xerox, who started out as a sales rep for the company in 1976 and took the top job in 2001. In an HBS case study mentioned in Bower's book, Mulcahy drew counsel from a wide constituency of friends and acquaintances at the company to help set its future direction based on color printers and office services. Xerox has since rebounded from near death to be a $16 billion player in the document industry.

Promoting from within is no promise of success, of course. Former Merrill Lynch CEO Stan O'Neal was with the company 21 years before his forced resignation on October 30. But strong leadership and effective succession programs are a hallmark of top-performing companies in general, says Bower.

Succession planning is hard work: It must be embraced by the organization and driven by the CEO. In the book, Bower identifies best practices companies can follow to identify, groom, and train internal candidates for the C-suite.

We asked Bower, an expert on corporate strategy, organization, and leadership, to draw on his 40 years of research and teaching experience at Harvard Business School to discuss the issues surrounding CEO succession.

Sean Silverthorne: What's wrong with the way most companies today pick CEOs?

Joseph Bower: For most companies, succession is an event to be managed with an ad hoc process. CEOs and their boards seem to believe they have done their job if there is a "name in the envelope." That means if the CEO is hit by a truck, they know who to appoint.

But this is nothing like a well-managed succession process that takes many years and is part and parcel of the way the company is managed..

Q: Why haven't organizations thought more about succession?

A: Succession is awkward for most boards and CEOs. It is associated with failure or a kind of death. Giving up power is not pleasant. So many CEOs don't want to talk about it. At best they think it makes them a lame duck. At worst, they may want to avoid leaving. So a board member might ask, "Don't you think we should discuss succession? You might get hit by a truck." And the CEO will say, "I have a successor in mind, and I've told John [the chair of the Compensation Committee] who it is."

Some variant of that conversation can go on for years. If that is all that has happened about succession, then when the time comes, the board may have to go outside.

Q: You argue that the best candidate for the top job is an internal candidate who has developed an outsider's perspective. What do you mean by that?

A: Well, internal is pretty clear. The great advantage of an internal candidate is that he or she knows the people, systems, and culture of the company. That means the candidate knows the company's strengths and weaknesses, who can be relied upon to help change things, where world-class competence does or does not reside, and how things can best be transformed.

But with all that understanding often comes a tacit or explicit belief in the appropriateness of "what we are trying to do and how we are doing it." You need an outside perspective to have a true, even brutal, understanding of what needs to change if the company is to succeed in the competitive environment that lies ahead. The inside-outsider knows that if his or her vision of the way the world is headed is remotely right, then real change is needed and he or she has the understanding of the company and confidence of its people to drive that transformation.

Q: At an organizational level, how should companies build a succession program?

A: Companies don't build succession programs, their CEOs do. The CEO has to want to manage the company so that potential leaders can develop.

That means having a chief talent officer to drive a many-faceted program that finds and builds great leaders. It means recruiting and training so that leaders can grow, but also managing compensation and promotion with development in mind. It means organizing the company so that up-and-coming talent can run the whole business early in their career. It means managing budgeting and planning so that it is a learning experience, not a cynical game of "gotcha." It means the CEO investing his or her time, and that of the board, so that everyone gets to know and appreciate the qualities of the potential leaders.

Q: What happens when your firm has not done proper succession planning, and needs to find a new CEO quickly?

A: Well, inevitably you bring in a search firm to help with the process. There will tend to be a bias in the search against insiders. Sometimes, the board will turn to a past CEO to serve in the interim, but sometimes that period provides time for a quick look at a younger insider. Usually the insiders will look incomplete, while the outsiders will look like an imperfect match. But given the record of outsiders, one might want to work with an insider rather than turning to an outsider riding in on a white horse. I'd rather have an Anne Mulcahy than a Bob Nardelli (CEO of Chrysler) or even a Jim Kilts (former CEO of Gillette).

Q: In a company that does manage succession well, what role should a CEO play in choosing his or her successor?

A: Developing the cohort of potential successors is one of the principal jobs of the CEO. It can't be done unless the CEO is driving that process—remember, the process is a critical part of how the company is managed over a period of years. It's not an event. The board needs to help with discussion, independent assessment, informed suggestions, and eventually a choice. But the board can't do the job.

Q: Are there times when an insider is not the best choice for CEO?

A: Absolutely. It may be essential to go outside when there are ethical lapses that seem embedded in the culture of the company. That seems to have happened at Siemens, maybe Boeing—I'm not close enough to know. But those boards went outside to demonstrate the seriousness of the problem and their intent to resolve it. It may also be essential when there has been a real breakdown in competence at the top.

Q: What advice would you give the board of Merrill Lynch as it searches for a replacement for CEO Stan O'Neal?

A: Look inside to see who might be able to do the job. But the choice will have to reassure the Street. In finance, credit depends on reputation, so the insider will have to be credible. It will really help Merrill if there is a well-liked and well-respected member of the team who can be brought forward to lead. But the board will have to help that person succeed—through close involvement of 2 or 3 key directors—coaching, advising, listening, and supporting. These are difficult markets.

Executive Summery

Who is the best CEO candidate? An insider with intimate knowledge of your company, or an outsider who is ready to put sacred cows out to pasture? The answer, says HBS professor Joseph L. Bower, is both. In this Q&A, he discusses his new book, The CEO Within, and why inside-outsiders are the key to succession planning. Key concepts include:

Effective succession planning is hallmark of many top-performing companies, but most firms pay little attention to the process.

In many cases an ideal candidate for CEO will come from inside but carry an outsider's perspective.



Best Jokes, Best Friends, Best Food. Get all this and more on Best of Yahoo! Groups.

Monday, June 2, 2008

The 20 Habits That Hold You Back from the Top

David Nour

If you do nothing else over the holidays, pick up Marshall Goldsmith's simple yet consistently Marshall-esque and direct book, What Got You Here Won't Get You There: How Successful People Become Even More Successful.

I recently had a chance to meet Marshall at the Vistage International 50th anniversary conference. His unassuming presence completely disarms you with the fact that he is the personal coach to some of the Fortune 500's most elite CEOs..

Early on in his book, he references the most annoying interpersonal issues in the workplace today. We thought these might be a relevant reference point as many deter you from developing intentional, strategic, and thus quantifiable business relationships.

For example, he talks about the importance of knowing when to stop. Have you ever thought about the stupid things top people do that they need to stop doing now? Get out a notepad and instead of the usual "to do" list, start a "to stop" list.

Goldsmith points out that not all behaviors can be categorized as good or bad. Many are simply neutral. In 2008, if you choose to be nicer, for example, instead of creating a long list of positive actions such as complimenting people, saying please and thank you, listening more patiently, and treating them with verbal respect (often a daunting task), a simpler way that doesn't require much effort at all is to just stop being a jerk! You don't have to think of ways to be nicer, all you really have to do is nothing! When someone offers a less than stellar plan, don't criticize – just say nothing! If your decisions are challenged, don't argue or make excuses – just quietly consider it and keep your critiques to yourself.

Before fixing bad behavior, you first have to identify the most common faults. These are not flaws of skill, intelligence, or unchangeable personality, but often challenges in interpersonal and leadership behavior. Many of our flaws are transactional and performed one person against another.

The 20 Habits That Hold You Back from the Top

1. Winning too much. The need to win at all costs and in all situations even when wining doesn't really matter and is totally beside the point.

2. Adding too much value. The overwhelming desire to add our opinion to every discussion.

3. Passing judgment. The need to impose our standards on others.

4. Making destructive comments.. Needless sarcasm and cutting remarks that we think make us sound sharp and witty.

5. Starting anything with "no, but or however." Seldom anything good comes after these and as negative qualifiers, they secretly say to everyone, "I am right and you are wrong."

6. Telling the world how smart we are. The need to show people we are smarter than they think we are.

7. Speaking when angry. Using emotional volatility as a management tool.

8. Negativity. "Let me explain why that won't work" is a need to share our negative thoughts even when we were not asked.

9. Withholding information. The refusal to share information in order to maintain control or an advantage over others.

10. Failing to give proper recognition. The inability to praise and reward.

11. Claiming credit that we don't deserve. The most annoying way to overestimate our contribution to any success.

12. Making excuses. The need to reposition our annoying behavior as a permanent fixture so people excuse us for it.

13. Clinging to the past. The need to deflect blame away from ourselves and onto events and people from our past.

14. Playing favorites. Failing to see that we are treating someone unfairly.

15. Refusing to express regret. The inability to take responsibility for our actions, admit we're wrong, or recognize how our actions affect others.

16. Not listening. The most passive aggressive form of disrespect of colleagues.

17. Failing to express gratitude. The most basic form of bad manners.

18. Punishing the messenger. The misguided need to attack the innocent who are usually only trying to help us.

19. Passing the buck. The need to blame everyone but ourselves.

20. An excessive need to be "me." Exalting our faults as virtues simply because they make us who we are.

Check yourself against the list. Though it is unlikely you are guilty of all of these annoying habits, you can probably narrow the list to 1-2 vital issues that will show you where to begin in 2008 and beyond.



Share files, take polls, and make new friends - all under one roof. Click here.